If you did IVF, did you do a DNA test on baby?

rated by 0 users
This post has 15 Replies | 0 Followers

Page 1 of 1 (16 items)
Top 200 Contributor
Posts 1,583
Maygirl17 Posted: Thu, Apr 19 2012 7:09 AM

I know this is a bit out there, but it just occurred to me the other day.  I have no reason to doubt my clinic and I trust them completely, but we've all read the scary stories of embryos mix-ups in the lab, so - if you did IVF, did you ever think or do a DNA test on baby to see if he/she was really yours? 

Was discussing this with DH last night, and it hadn't occurred to him at all, and I don't honestly know that I'd want to do it anyway - these babies are mine regardless of anything, though I guess for medical reasons it might be good to know (inherited conditions, etc.).  But if you've thought about it or done it, I'd love your input. Thanks. 

Kiss DH (36) Me (35)  Ovulate on my own, no MF issues, infertility unexplained (after over 4 years of IF, possibly endo??).  Failed Treatments: 3 rounds of Clomid (1 IUI); 2 rounds of injectibles (2 IUIs), and one IVF - all with great response but BFN.  FET # 1 (November 2011) (with acupuncture) - BFP!  It's twins!  Baby BoyBaby Girl (Betas: 9dp5dt - 371; 11dp5dt - 726; born at 36 weeks).  IVF # 2 - September 2014 BFN; FET # 2 - December 2014 - BFP Baby (Betas: 8dp5dt - 38.7; 10dp5dt - 102)


Top 50 Contributor
Posts 6,512
piper replied on Thu, Apr 19 2012 7:28 AM

Did I do it?  no

Would I do it? no

Have I thought about it?  of course!

I remember when they did the transfer I had to look at a screen and they asked me for my full name and ssn and date of birth - after I answered they showed me the label that had the same info - then I was able to watch as they removed the Embryo and sucked it into the catheter and then handed it to the Doctor and he inserted it...... bit still in the back of my mind I was like "how do I know if it was DH's sperm?  How do I know they didnt mix it up in the lab??"

At the end of the day though I dont care if he is mine biologically or not he is my child and I carried him for 9 months and held him the moment he was born - so he IS mine Heart

I will say though I know he is ours.... he looks EXACTLY like my DH!!!! Laugh

me: 36 Kiss  DH: 46

Baby Boy Sept 2008 - IVF/ICSI

Baby Girl March 2011 - au natural




Not Ranked
Posts 477
shelleys replied on Thu, Apr 19 2012 7:31 AM

Wow, I never even heard or thought of this but now that the seed is planted, I suppose the same thing could happen during IUI as well (with DH's sperm). It's something I might consider down the line (need to get pg first), as long as it's not astronomically expensive or harmful in any way. Though I suppose as someone who's open to adoption but also desperately wants to carry a baby myself - it really truly doesn't matter. But I know what you mean, it'd be nice to know for sure. That's a privilege the fertiles get that you don't often think of.

Shelley (29), DH (29) Kiss
Together since 9/14/02, Married since 9/19/09.

TTC #1 since June 2010, Diagnosed w/Unexplained Infertility: January 2012

Baby Girl - 5/13 - Conceived via FET #1, born with gastroschisis but doing great now Yes 

3/10 - Blighted Ovum Angel
1/12 - Chemical following IUI Angel
9/12 - Vanishing twin Angel
10/14 - Ectopic (right tube removed) Angel 

My IF blog

Top 200 Contributor
Posts 1,583
Maygirl17 replied on Thu, Apr 19 2012 10:06 AM

Thanks for your input, ladies.  Nice to know I am not the only one who thought of it, though I am definitely with you, Piper - it doesn't really matter.  I suppose it'll be interesting to see who they look like!

Kiss DH (36) Me (35)  Ovulate on my own, no MF issues, infertility unexplained (after over 4 years of IF, possibly endo??).  Failed Treatments: 3 rounds of Clomid (1 IUI); 2 rounds of injectibles (2 IUIs), and one IVF - all with great response but BFN.  FET # 1 (November 2011) (with acupuncture) - BFP!  It's twins!  Baby BoyBaby Girl (Betas: 9dp5dt - 371; 11dp5dt - 726; born at 36 weeks).  IVF # 2 - September 2014 BFN; FET # 2 - December 2014 - BFP Baby (Betas: 8dp5dt - 38.7; 10dp5dt - 102)


Top 500 Contributor
Posts 1,088
zzdeleted62686 replied on Thu, Apr 19 2012 11:22 AM

It was the first thing my husband thought of when he realized a pill wasn't going to fix me and we would need to undergo IUI and subsequently IVF.  He was literally freaked out and kept himself up for a night or two before he settled down and this was no longer his big worry.  He discussed his biggest worry with the RE who explained all the medical policy and procedures they had in place to ensure this did not happen.  So, now he doesn't even bat an eye when we go through the ART process.

However, I've left the window open if DH, when we do get our take home baby to do any type of DNA testing to make him feel some sense of relief.  For me personally, I don't feel like I need it but it's my obligation to also hear my husbands concerns and do what I can to help him.  So, if one of us felt the need to confirm that this child is biologically ours then we will do the DNA testing for the others peace of mind.  But it's not like regardless of the results either one of us would return the baby so I guess if one of those weird crazy out of the extraordinary circumstances happened where malicious or not DNA was mixed up we'd need to seek therapy and figure a way to move forward.

I don't think there's a right or wrong answer but you're not alone in having 'wondered' about this before or consider testing as an option.  I think someone on these boards tried make my husband seem like he was overly concerned or needed therapy for this big worry of his way back when we first saw an RE.  While I appreciated whomever's opinion that was (I don't even recall), I thought her opinion was way judgemental of my husband for basically suggesting that we shouldn't be seeking ART if he was that bent up over it.

I suppose you'll decide what you'll do or not do once the baby comes.  I can't believe you're almost there!

Not Ranked
Posts 298
aplatanada replied on Thu, Apr 19 2012 11:52 AM

Our clinic has very strict rules about your "deposits."  They have to be dropped off at specific time and they won't even let people wait in the andrology area.  They don't test on various samples at the same time, either.  We have to visually recognize the name on the sample before the IUI (we aren't at IVF yet).   Basically, the procedures they have in place make us pretty confident that our swimmers are ours.

Besides, I am white and DH is black/Latino, so I think it would be pretty easy to see if it wasn't his swimmer that got the deed done.  Big Smile (Knock wood that we EVER get to that place!)

If there were any doubt, I could see wanting to know, if nothing else to have an accurate medical history for my child. I don't think it's an odd thing to wonder about.

Me (Leslie): 35 DH: 47

TTC#1since 11/2010, Diagnosed unexplained infertility in 11/2011

Clomid + timed intercourse: 4 cycles, 4 BFNs
Clomid +  IUI #1: BFN
April 2012 attempt at Clomid IUI failed, CBE digitals failed to detect the surge
Clomid +  IUI #2: BFN
IVF 9/2012 BFP! Twins! BabyBaby

Top 50 Contributor
Posts 7,693
southernbelle replied on Thu, Apr 19 2012 2:14 PM

No DNA test.  No need, really.  She has my face & eye color and her dad's lanky body type. Smile

Johanna Heart DH 10-23-04

Not Ranked
Posts 451
alicat replied on Fri, Apr 20 2012 6:24 PM

Next to worrying about baby's health and safe arrival, this was my biggest concern.  I remember stressing after the FET because I couldn't remember if they verified our info against the embryo info at transfer.  (DH assured me they did, so I think I was just loopy from the Valium.)  I would have had a DNA test if I really thought there was a mixup.  However, both kids look exactly like DH and me.  So there is no doubt that they are 100% genetically ours. 

Me (35), DH (37), DD (3), DS (1) 

Top 500 Contributor
Posts 696
nell replied on Sat, Apr 21 2012 9:22 AM

I would think (hope) statistically this is as rare as babies being swopped at birth in a hospital.....and every parent has potential for that , even non ART pg.

It hadn't occurred to me really tbh as our clinic always seem so stringent with that side of things, I guess i'll cross that bridge when I get to it though as i've no take home baby just yet :)


Me 32yrs, DH 37yrs

Chronic spotter from 4DPO, Small intramural fibroids, Low AMH yet also PCO.

3 fresh IVF's - 2 BFN and 1 chemical pregnancy. All with thin endometrium Sad 1 FETCancelled due to thin endometrium, just 5mm

FET March 2012. Low beta, just 20 at 9dp5dt and a super squinter on a FRER, doubling nicely. HB seen but measuring 6 days behind. Scan at 7w+4 back on track. Baby Baby Girl born November 2012.

Back for a sibling FET July 2013 - BFP, no squinter this time Smile 6w+6 scan shows twins, 8w+3 shows triplets. Identical twins passed away at 11 weeks and 12 weeks, cause unknown. Singleton still ok.

Not Ranked
Posts 396
Dmstvr12 replied on Mon, Apr 23 2012 2:44 PM

DS looks so much like us, there is no question. We've never discussed it.

Dorothy (30) DH (31) Dealing with unexplained severe MFI

IVF #1 - Baby Boy ICSI miracle baby boy born 5/22/10 at 37.4 weeks due to low fluid

IVF #2, #3, #4 - 2 chemicals & a BFN

FET #1, #2 - BFN, and embryos didn't survive the thaw

IVF #5 - New doctor, new protocol. OMG, BFP!!!!  TWIN BOYS Baby Boy Baby Boy born at 34.5 weeks 4/10/13

Not Ranked
Posts 931
MommyBlessedWith2 replied on Mon, Apr 23 2012 9:47 PM

In the very solemn and stressful world of IF treatments, this was one area where we found humor.  During pregnancy #1 (IUI) and #3 (IVF), my DH would periodically joke about the chances of the baby not being his.  (As mentioned, the labs are super-secure, and the odds of that happening HAVE to be similar to being struck by lightning or winning the lottery.  It happens, but...)

Those two children look EXACTLY like him.  I joke that this is God's answer to him for all the teasing!

Me: 38 Heart Him: 38 (Severe MFI: SAs show between 4-6 sperm per sample)
DD: 10 (our IUI miracle), DS: 8 (our surprise baby), Baby Boy: 1 (our IVF miracle)

Dec. 2010: IVF #1 after 2.5 years TTC = Sad
June 2011: Transferred our 1 frozen snowbaby with many prayers - Final shot at one more child = Our newest miracle

3 babies - 3 different types of conception.  Praising God for miracles in all forms!

Top 500 Contributor
Posts 1,090
cand82 replied on Mon, Apr 23 2012 10:11 PM

Its crossed both DH and my minds before. How can it not? We joke about it sometimes, but like the PPs said clinics have very strict protocols so the right samples end up where they are supposed to be so that neither sperm nor eggs are mixed up. There's a very, very, very slim chance there could be a mix up of course, but we have never seriously considered double checking DS's genetics. That said DS is a mixture of both DH and I so we've never had any suspicions of a mix up. And as the PPs said even if he wasn't genetically ours he IS ours!

Lilypie Second Birthday tickers

Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers

Top 500 Contributor
Posts 930
laurenAZ replied on Mon, Apr 23 2012 11:17 PM

I can't tell you how relieving it is to hear I'm not the only one who has thought about this!  We also try to find humor in the situation.  To our utter shock, my son popped out as an unmistakable and completely adorable redhead (neither of us have red hair).  DS looks just like my husband so the sperm is definitely his, but I do often joke that there is a beautiful redheaded woman out there missing an egg!

In all seriousness though, I wouldn't do DNA testing.  Ignorance is bliss.  I love my son, I love my life, why mess with that?

Me - 33  DH - 33

Birth Doula and Certified Lactation Educator

TTC #1 since 6/08

TTC #2 since 4/12

Angel  8/31/09 @ 5wk4d

12/28/09 - Follow-up with RE.  FSH level is 12.9. On to IVF.

February 2010 - IVF #1.  20 retrieved, 18 fertilized. 5-day ET of 2 perfect AAA blasts.  BFN.

April 6, 2010 - FET #1 of 2 blasts.  BFP on 4/16!  HCG: 158 @ 10dp5dt ,  HCG: 926 at 14dp5dt

Baby Boy born December 22, 2010 - 9 lbs. 1 oz!

April 2012 - began TTC #2.  Clomid 50mg,100mg, 150mg, 200mg = BFN

April 2013 - surprise BFP immediately after we gave up TTC and put down non-refundable deposit for FET


Lilypie Pregnancy tickers

Top 500 Contributor
Posts 1,067
KattMC replied on Tue, Apr 24 2012 2:16 PM

Funny, DH and I used to joke about this too.  They always did make us triple check the name at various points throughout the process so I wasn't too concerned.  I would never get a DNA test no matter what, but my daughter is truly my husband's mini me.  She looks nothing like me though Wink

Me 29 ~ DH 37

Baby Girl Alexa Sloane ~ 10/9/11 ~ Born at 39+3 ~ TTC 1 year, 6 IUIs ~

Baby Girl Bria Quinn ~ 9/12/13 ~ Born at 39+2 ~ TTC 4 months, clomid ~

~ Thin PCOS ~ TTA indefinitely ~


Top 200 Contributor
Posts 1,583
Maygirl17 replied on Tue, Apr 24 2012 3:01 PM

Thanks for the input, ladies, I am happy to see I am not the only crazy one having these thoughts.  Congratulations to everyone on your little blessings. :)

Kiss DH (36) Me (35)  Ovulate on my own, no MF issues, infertility unexplained (after over 4 years of IF, possibly endo??).  Failed Treatments: 3 rounds of Clomid (1 IUI); 2 rounds of injectibles (2 IUIs), and one IVF - all with great response but BFN.  FET # 1 (November 2011) (with acupuncture) - BFP!  It's twins!  Baby BoyBaby Girl (Betas: 9dp5dt - 371; 11dp5dt - 726; born at 36 weeks).  IVF # 2 - September 2014 BFN; FET # 2 - December 2014 - BFP Baby (Betas: 8dp5dt - 38.7; 10dp5dt - 102)


Not Ranked
Posts 78
LauraB replied on Tue, Jul 10 2012 7:22 PM

I'm at the beginning of my ART journey, so I have not yet had the opportunity. Even if I became concerned about it, I think I would decline to test. I heard a radio documentary about a couple in NY who had another couple's embryo transferred by error. The genetic parents' legal rights trumped those of the birth mother, rendering the birth mother an accidental gestational surrogate. It was the clinic who discovered the error, but, in that circumstance, perhaps ignorance really would have been bliss. I think the best approach for me is to ensure my clinic employs best practices and then trust (what will hopefully be) the result. 

If you're interested, here is the podcast:

Warning: this story is so heartbreaking that I was crying for some time after the program ended and teared up regularly in the following days whenever I thought of it. It is a tough listen!


Me (31) & DH (30) married 2004

TTC since April 2010

Endometriosis: Lap in August 2004 and again in Feb 2011

Subclinical hypothyroid

I also have a few autoimmune conditions  

2 rambunctious vizsla furchildren

IUI September 6, 2012 (femara days 3-7, hcg trigger Sept 5)


Page 1 of 1 (16 items) | RSS